A neighborhood of families rush home for the holidays, ready to share in the chaos and joy of the season. Josh Hill is back in town, and runs into Nora, his high school crush. Only nowadays, she is the local Sheriff and can issue him driving infractions, which she does.

Josh and Nora were lab partners in high school, both assuming each was out of their league while harboring a secret crush on the other. Nora is the small town’s sheriff, recently widowed and raising her son Theo alone. While tasked with some community service under Nora’s supervisions, Josh and Theo forge a connection, bringing Josh and Norah closer while he’s home for the holidays.

Ted and Marcus are celebrating their engagement with Ted’s family this Christmas. Ted isn't “out” to Grandma Lin, which leads to a misunderstanding that Marcus is engaged to Ted's sister, Ella. Stars Osric Chau and Lucielle Soong.

Lucy and her sister Sylvie have been at odds since their Mom’s sudden passing when they were kids. Now, as adults, Sylvie’s home for Hanukkah and wants to spice things up. Stars Lindy Booth and Rachelle Leferve.

Linda brings home her younger boyfriend Evan for the holidays, to her family and ex-husband Robert's surprise. But Robert and Evan may have more in common than not. Stars Dennis Haysbert, Loretta Devine, and Ser'Darius Blain.

Gaby's family traditions are thwarted by Katie, her former high school bully and her brother's current girlfriend. Will their rivalry come between the couple's first Christmas together? Stars Noemi Gonzalez and Holland Roden.

The Manetti-Hanahans are that family that everyone wishes would just move already. Fed up with her family’s “poke fun to show love” chaos and her husband’s “we’ve gone too far” light display that’s made him the most hated man on the cul-de-sac, Connie Manetti-Hanahan forces her family to sign a “no conflict contract” this Christmas. That goes as well as you think it would.

Each family episode ends with a blackout—only one house is left with power. Ugh, it’s the Manetti-Hanahans, because naturally they’ve employed backup generators for Chuck’s light display. All families are invited to celebrate Christmas Day at the one house they never thought they’d end up at—and it’s just enough to remind folks that family might be complicated, but there’s nothing like yours.